Will Democrats Let the Senate Parliamentarian Stand in the Way of Immigration Reform?

Fight corruption. Receive daily updates on important topics. Sign up for the free Mother Jones newsletter.
In a bid to bolster Democrats with immigration protection in Biden’s Build Back Better Bill, lawmakers opposed a plan to prevent deportation and work permits for millions of undocumented and undocumented immigrants in the United States. It is also a surprising example of how a filibuster has joined forces with the Senate to stop violent reforms.

To cross the filibuster, Democrats have tried to manipulate the budget – which can be done by agreement, requiring only a majority of 51 votes. But to do so supply must follow you Byrd, which requires the entire state to be affected on the joint floor. spending and revenue are not “accidental.” It is for Sen. Elizabeth MacDonough to determine if offers meet this requirement.

On Thursday, MacDonough, an unnamed official who played a key role in advising on council hearings, published a short guide arguing that the decision would lead to “policy change with long-term impact” and beyond finance.

This is the third time MacDonough, a former emissary prosecutor, has rejected proposals to turn embezzlement into $ 2 trillion of social and environmental spending. The first program will create a civic program for Dreamers who come to the country as children, special staff, part-time agents, and farm workers (in accordance with Biden’s original plan). After thinking he did not go, a second Democrat option was made to MacDonough, which he also rejected, with an update on a provision in the so-called “registration” law that allowed some long-term visitors without permits. legal residence. Under the newly introduced version known as Plan C, nearly 6.5 million immigrants living in the United States by 2011 will be pardoned with temporary relief from their five-year departure together with the possibility of a one-time update. They will also be eligible for a work permit and a travel permit. That met his deadline yesterday.

Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer and other federal Democrats wrote in a joint statement: Ways to Succeed Citizenship in Better Building Law. “” Through the mediation process, we have worked to ensure that corrective action is not treated as a stumbling block. ”

The MP’s opinion is incorrect on Ms. The obvious impact of the budget and the coming decades comes by changing the policy by agreement. We must pursue all options to pave the way for the citizen, including that of Dreams and special staff.

– Elizabeth Warren (@SenWarren) December 17, 2021

The short-term protection provided by the amnesty program goes far beyond the one-year-old pact to rehabilitate the practice, which took place in 1986 under President Ronald Reagan. “For decades, migrants seeking relief from the right to fly from a temporary location to a so-called home country,” 90 lawmakers wrote in a letter in November calling on the Senate and with citizens in the their branch. reconciliation paper.

“With the outbreak, most people do not have Christmas or birthdays together. This is an immigrant life day and night.”
Karina Ruiz knows the sense of this fact in her mixed family. The 37-year-old 37-year-old Native American came to Phoenix, Arizona from Mexico in 1999 at the age of 15. She was promoted under the Obama-era Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals. DACA) 2013 and must be updated four times since then. . In 2017, Ruiz was able to visit Mexico for the first time in 18 years through the next amnesty, but with DACA under constant threat, Ruiz and the rest of Dreams left them in limbo. When his father died of COVID in November 2020, Ruiz was allowed to travel for his funeral in Oaxaca, but his unlicensed mother could not be found. He told me: “I was happy to be with her at that time and to say good-bye to her. “With the outbreak, most people do not have Christmas or birthdays together. This is an immigrant life day and night.”

Ruiz’s father, Vicente Fernández, a sweet but hard-working man who could not drive but cycled, died at the age of 74 without seeing his other children in Mexico for more than 20 years. “[My mom] and my sister FaceTime every day because they both fear something might happen because of the disease,” Ruiz said. “I can see the fear in them that they will not be able to hug at last.”

Karina Ruiz visits her father’s grave in Mexico. Karina Ruiz
Ruiz knows that paragraphs are not the perfect solution, as is DACA. But it is better than nothing. “We are committed to being a citizen and we will continue to fight for it,” he said during an immigrant rights conference in Washington DC in mid-December. “But if what is possible and possible for Congress is to protect immigrants, work permits, and the ability to come back to see those who are interested, that will change our lives. abundant.”

Democrats may also decide to oppose parliamentary views, something activists and activists have been calling for for a long time but seemingly impossible. Senator Joe Manchin (D-W.Va.) Has already announced his opposition to leaving the Senate. Democrats have previously avoided legislating because of concerns about its decision.

On Friday, White House press secretary Jen Psaki described the move by lawmakers as “disappointing.” “Finally, it is time for Congress to stop small arms fire on the road and finally provide reassurance and stability to these parties and make significant changes to the previous action plan,” he said.

Fight corruption. Receive daily updates on important topics. Sign up for the free Mother Jones newsletter.
Thousands of migrants chill in hot weather in a forest on the Belarusian-Polish border. A “shadow scheme” that threw asylum seekers into rebel-held prisons in Libya to prevent them from going to Europe. Cubans were forcibly deported from Greece to Turkey. “We live in a time of obstacles and obstacles,” Pope Francis said during a visit to a refugee camp on the Greek island of Lesbos. “Let’s stop this shipwreck of civilization!”

Traffic is tightening border controls and identifying the old area as a safe haven for the weak and seeking security these days. But facing its own challenges at the US-Mexico border, the Biden government is seeking encouragement from Europe on how to better accommodate and manage asylum seekers.

Earlier this week, the Washington Post reported that government officials were reviewing recommendations of border posts similar to those held in countries such as Germany, Switzerland and Sweden between 2015 and 2016, in response to the stream. of many immigrants. Afghanistan, and other asylum seekers. Under this model, visitors will be in a “non-physical environment with access to educational programs, medical services, and legal advisers” while reviewing their legal security. If they fail to be legally protected, they will be removed. “We are still in the process of developing a strategy, but as we enter the second year of this administration, there will be a lot of focus on making meaningful reforms to our asylum system and how we process researchers refuge. at the border, “one. The official told the newspaper.

Some behavioral experts and consultants have found the substance with skepticism and caution.

When is prison not a prison? When the “non-carceral collection center” comes with an ankle splint and threatens to catch you if you go before you can leave. https://t.co/5U4dvuDp2i

– David Bennion (@dcbenion) December 14, 2021

Jones’ mother told Yael Schacher, a senior consultant in the United States at Refugees International and the author of a forthcoming book on the history of asylum seekers in the United States, about the status of recruitment companies in Europe and what jobs they have. if any, it’s.American should be. Borrow them:

According to the Washington Post, Biden government officials view European asylum seekers as examples. What are you doing with it?

My point is to say that we need new ideas on how to manage a large number of asylum seekers at the border and that there are some good products in Europe, but most of them are problematic. One of the big flags for me is the fact that some of the products they are looking for are not only problems, but not states ahead. For example, Germany is not the first country where there are people, they had a large number when the Syrian refugee group took place in 2015 and 2016, but for the most part, Germany did not receive numbers almost equal to what we have . at the border (US-Mexico), where there are 5,000 to 7,000 people coming daily.

The future of European countries, places like Greece or Spain, will go to the most suffering types of reception, imminent access. The situation of migrants on Greek islands has received a lot of attention for cruelty, and as a result, the Greek government has set up five useful centers to accommodate asylum seekers, but they look like prisons. There is a monitor, a wire fence, and it is the constant security of a private company. Camp residents face security checks on entry and NGO officials say children under the age of 10 are thoroughly screened before being allowed to return after school. Conditions are somewhat higher in low-income refugee camps, but of course what happens is for asylum seekers. And the whole European Union is giving aid to Greece because it is the first country to keep people in Greece and prevent them from moving to Europe.

I am worried that perhaps the fact that the United States is comparing itself to Germany instead of Spain or Greece could indicate that the Biden government is also planning to enter into a third treaty with Mexico so that we can be like Germany and the leading country. . We will allow Mexico to accept people and we will bring those who can testify that Mexico is not safe for them to relocate. But now, we look more like Greece and Spain.

What are some of the successes and failures of different European hospitality companies?

Some European markets – such as in Switzerland and Germany – are based on the idea of ​​focusing on people in one world but dispersing them across the country. They are very small; not that most people belong to themselves because otherwise they have become great masses. But some of these are in very small places, so it leaves you alone, and their conditions are different. In Germany, they focus more on different countries of asylum seekers at different reception centers, so different countries have different positions – some better, some worse. These countries also provide financial assistance to asylum seekers.

People stay at these reception centers for two months, and they are allowed to leave during the day and return at night. The length is too long because the asylum claim is judged while living in the reception center. Sweden had a well-developed brand that by first registering and making people legal, but then quickly settled in the area. Reception centers, in some cases, are more like a way of treating children who are not [in the United States], where they are sent to temporary shelters and then sent back to the sponsor or to debtors. the area where they received post-divorce divorce services. It has been very successful especially with regard to people who have been denied asylum: About 70 percent of them have agreed to leave the country at the end of the process, which is a good idea of ​​what kind of opening program.

Many pundits are skeptical about the feasibility of such products in the United States, with some saying it could easily turn into “kids in a cage” and family custody 2.0.

I think the devil is in the details right now, and the details are missing. There are many issues such as getting advice, access to jobs, freedom of movement, and how long a person will stay in these institutions. I do not think any of them are on the scale of what we are going to do with the border here and they all have positive and negative signs. I’m not saying don’t look at Europe, but think carefully about how we can do that by measuring the number of people who come to America. The question is, can we make such arrangements for the collection and integration we need? That is the real challenge. I was a little worried that it would end up in the near future of the family planning program.

“I’m not saying don’t look at Europe, but think carefully about how we can do that to measure the number of people who come to America.”
What most of us in the consulting community would expect is a human system far removed from the carceral model. The program will allow for legal and regulatory actions and should not be governed by Customs and Border Protection (CBP), as it is dangerous to print such tent materials used for viewing in Texas – or in If we delay in receiving these. companies if we need to judge when they are there than after the record. I want us to choose and think about how to use these products.